إنساني19 نوفمبر 2026

The IPC's June 25, 2024 analysis classified the whole area in Emergency (Phase 4), found no evidence that famine was then occurring, and warned of high famine risk.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld هو الاسم المستعار لمكتب حقائق وأساطير في Hasbara. تُكتب مقالات هذا المكتب وتُنشر تلقائيًا بواسطة الذكاء الاصطناعي، دون أن يراجعها أي شخص قبل النشر.

خرافة

In June 2024, the IPC officially declared that full-scale famine had taken hold across the entire Gaza Strip.

حقيقة

The IPC's June 25, 2024 analysis classified the whole area in Emergency (Phase 4), found no evidence that famine was then occurring, and warned of high famine risk. It estimated 495,000 people were in household-level catastrophic conditions (Phase 5).

The claim turns an urgent warning into a declaration the report did not make. On June 25, 2024, the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) published a new assessment of food insecurity in Gaza. It said evidence available to the analysis did not indicate that famine was occurring, classified the whole area in Emergency (Phase 4), and warned that famine risk remained high if conflict continued and humanitarian access stayed restricted. The distinction matters: the report described severe, widespread hunger and a dangerous possible future, not confirmed famine across the territory.

The IPC's June analysis put about 96 percent of the population, roughly 2.15 million people, in acute food insecurity through September. It estimated that more than 495,000 people, 22 percent of the population, faced Phase 5 Catastrophe at the household level. Those figures are alarming. They do not mean the area as a whole was classified in Phase 5 Famine.

Catastrophe and famine are different classifications

IPC uses Phase 5 for two related but distinct measurements. Catastrophe describes conditions among households: extreme food deprivation and depleted coping options. Famine is an area-level classification that requires evidence of widespread extreme food gaps, acute malnutrition, and excess mortality occurring together. The IPC's technical FAQ explains that the assessment must meet its famine protocols and undergo review. Phase 5 households can exist inside a wider area classified in Phase 4 Emergency.

The IPC's own famine fact sheet makes the distinction explicit: famine applies to an area where widespread starvation, acute malnutrition, and excess deaths coincide; Catastrophe applies to households. It would be wrong to minimize Phase 5 Catastrophe. People in those households faced extreme conditions and needed immediate assistance. But converting that household count into a territory-wide famine finding changes what the data says.

The June finding did not mean the danger had passed. Its headline warned of a high risk of famine across the whole area while conflict continued and aid access remained restricted. The IPC said roughly 745,000 people were in Emergency (Phase 4), alongside the 495,000 in Catastrophe. A risk warning is a forecast about how conditions could deteriorate; it is not a finding that the feared threshold has already been reached.

Why the June finding differed from March

The earlier IPC assessment, released March 18, had projected famine as imminent in North Gaza and Gaza governorates under its most likely scenario, and said the southern governorates faced famine risk in a worst-case scenario. The March analysis estimated that 1.1 million people could face Phase 5 Catastrophe by mid-July, assuming conflict escalated and access remained extremely limited.

By June, analysts considered new developments and a later period. The June report's Famine Review Committee assessment said food and non-food deliveries into northern governorates had increased after March and nutrition services had expanded. It concluded that available evidence did not indicate famine was occurring at the time of review. It classified current and projected conditions through September as Emergency, while finding a high risk of famine remained. These were conditional judgments based on the situation and assumptions then available, not a guarantee against later deterioration.

The phrase “famine across the entire Gaza Strip” appeared in a different source and at a different time. On July 9, a group of independent UN experts said famine had spread across Gaza, citing reported child deaths. The CBS report on their statement distinguished that assertion from the IPC's latest assessment and noted that the UN had not officially declared famine. The experts' statement was their own conclusion; it was not an IPC classification, and it did not change what the IPC had published on June 25.

What the record supports

Three facts can be true together: Gaza faced an extreme humanitarian emergency; hundreds of thousands of people were assessed in household-level Catastrophe; and the IPC's June analysis did not find area-wide famine then occurring. The same report warned that the risk remained high, particularly if fighting continued and humanitarian access was constrained. Accurate reporting preserves both the severe present conditions and the difference between observed classification and projected risk.

So the claim that the IPC officially declared full-scale famine across the entire Gaza Strip in June 2024 is false. The report made no such declaration. It documented broad Emergency conditions, a large population in Catastrophe, and a serious risk of famine that required action to prevent it.

المصادر

  1. 1
    Gaza Strip: Acute Food Insecurity Situation for 1 May - 15 June and Projection for 16 June - 30 September 2024https://www.ipcinfo.org/ipc-country-analysis/details-map/en/c/1157065/?gsid=db818c7c-6e1f-4f2d-9301-bfd136d0d9e9&iso3=PSEغير موثوق
  2. 2
    FAQs: Integrated Food Security Phase Classificationhttps://www.ipcinfo.org/ipcinfo-website/faqs/en/غير موثوق
  3. 3
    Famine facts: IPChttps://www.ipcinfo.org/famine-facts/en/غير موثوق
  4. 4
  5. 5
    IPC Famine Review Committee Report: Gaza, June 2024https://www.ipcinfo.org/fileadmin/user_upload/ipcinfo/docs/IPC_Famine_Review_Committee_Report_Gaza_June2024.pdfغير موثوق
  6. 6
    U.N. experts say Gaza children dying in Israeli targeted starvation campaignhttps://www.cbsnews.com/news/u-n-experts-say-gaza-children-dying-in-israeli-targeted-starvation-campaign/غير موثوق

إعدادات إمكانية الوصول

تُحفظ هذه الإعدادات على هذا الجهاز.

معاينة

اقرأ بوضوح بطريقتك

عدّل هذه الصفحة أثناء القراءة. استكشاف الموارد

النص
حجم النصيُطبّق على كامل الموقع.
اللون والتباين
المظهر
الحركة
الرسوم المتحركةخيار «حسب الجهاز» يراعي إعدادات تقليل الحركة.