إعلامي19 نوفمبر 2026

The photograph shows Israeli residents trying to pull a fellow resident away from Border Police during a September 13, 2009 clash at Havat Gilad.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld هو الاسم المستعار لمكتب حقائق وأساطير في Hasbara. تُكتب مقالات هذا المكتب وتُنشر تلقائيًا بواسطة الذكاء الاصطناعي، دون أن يراجعها أي شخص قبل النشر.

خرافة

Israeli residents are shown trying to tear an Arab child apart in this photograph.

حقيقة

The photograph shows Israeli residents trying to pull a fellow resident away from Border Police during a September 13, 2009 clash at Havat Gilad. It does not show a child or an attack on an Arab child.

A photograph recirculated online in June 2024 does not show Israeli residents trying to tear an Arab child apart. The image records a September 13, 2009 clash near Havat Gilad: Israeli residents are trying to pull a fellow resident away as Border Police drag him during an attempted arrest. AFP photographer Yehuda Raizner took the photograph, and both AFP’s archive and his account identify the person as an adult Israeli resident. The false caption changes the people, the action and the date.

The viral post appeared on X on June 26, 2024, with the caption “Settler savages try to tear a Palestinian child apart in the occupied West Bank.” It was also circulated in Arabic, Greek and Urdu, according to AFP. The dramatic image can look like several people are pulling one person in opposite directions. Its framing leaves out why they are there and who the person is. The caption converts a confrontation over a police arrest into an alleged assault on a child, despite the photograph’s older archive record.

What the original photograph records

AFP’s archive dates the image to September 13, 2009, and credits Raizner. Its caption says Border Police were dragging a fellow Israeli resident during clashes at the entrance to Havat Gilad, west of Nablus. Other residents tried to pull him back. Police had gone to confiscate a truck carrying materials for a new house. The scene was therefore a struggle around an arrest and police action involving construction materials, not an attack on a child.

Raizner gave AFP Fact Check a direct confirmation on July 4, 2024. He said the person in the image “was a settler who the police tried to arrest, and his other friends tried to avoid him from being arrested.” AFP also reported that police intervened to prevent residents from placing a trailer at the site. These details identify the subject and immediate circumstances through the photographer and the news agency’s dated photo archive, rather than through interpretation of the image alone.

Check Your Fact traced the image to Getty Images and reproduced the archive caption, which likewise identifies a fellow resident being dragged by border police. Jakarta’s public information and statistics agency checked the same viral image and found it identical to the Getty photograph. Its review also quotes Raizner’s identification of the person as someone police tried to arrest. These separate checks point to the same dated original and the same photographer attribution.

How the false caption changes the record

The image itself cannot establish the viral story. It contains no visible child identification, date or location label. Reposting it with a new caption supplies those details as assertions, but the older archive record contradicts them. The photograph predates the viral X post by nearly fifteen years. Its source caption identifies the man as a fellow resident, the uniformed officers as border police and the location as Havat Gilad. Raizner confirms that the officers were attempting an arrest.

The correction does not depend on deciding whether every action during the 2009 confrontation was lawful or justified. Those broader judgments are not what the image or the viral caption can establish. The specific factual question is whether the photograph depicts residents trying to tear a child apart. The original caption, photographer’s account and independent reviews all identify a different scene: an attempt by friends to prevent police from taking away a fellow resident.

The Jakarta agency classifies the post as false context, a useful description of the method. An authentic photograph can still mislead when separated from its date, caption and original event. Here, image matching connects the circulating copy to AFP’s older frame, while the archive supplies the setting and Raizner supplies first-hand identification. The evidence answers the viral allegation directly: the person is not an Arab child, and the scene is not an assault on one.

Accurate captions matter because photographs often travel farther than the reports that first explained them. The 2024 post presented the 2009 image as current proof of a severe crime. The records instead show Israeli residents struggling with police over the arrest of one of their companions during an operation at Havat Gilad. That correction preserves the actual event and prevents a misleading caption from turning an old arrest photograph into fabricated evidence of child abuse.

المصادر

  1. 1
  2. 2
    FACT CHECK: Viral X Image Does Not Show Israeli Settlers Trying To Tear Palestinian Child Aparthttps://checkyourfact.com/2024/06/28/fact-check-image-israeli-settlers-palestinian-child/غير موثوق
  3. 3
    Hoaks: Photo of Israeli residents pulling a childhttps://jalahoaks.jakarta.go.id/detail/HOAKS-FOTO-SEKELOMPOK-PEMUKIM-ILEGAL-ISRAEL-MENARIK-TUBUH-ANAK-PALESTINAغير موثوق

إعدادات إمكانية الوصول

تُحفظ هذه الإعدادات على هذا الجهاز.

معاينة

اقرأ بوضوح بطريقتك

عدّل هذه الصفحة أثناء القراءة. استكشاف الموارد

النص
حجم النصيُطبّق على كامل الموقع.
اللون والتباين
المظهر
الحركة
الرسوم المتحركةخيار «حسب الجهاز» يراعي إعدادات تقليل الحركة.